Find Real Estate Agents and Homes for Sale


Real Estate News --> Hawaii News

We Should Look Anew At Real Estate Investment Trusts


This past year Alexander & Baldwin announced, like many Hawaii commercial real estate companies before it, that it too, would become a real estate investment trust. At this rate, I too, would like to be a REIT, but alas, a REIT requires a minimum of 100 ...


Archived Story

With Alexander & Baldwin looking to become a REIT, it’s time to reassess this means of avoiding Hawaii income tax for out-of-staters By Andrea Carr / About 20 hours ago var addthis_config = addthis_config || {}; var addthis_share = { // ..other options url_transforms : { shorten: { twitter: 'bitly' } }, shorteners : { bitly : {} } }; addthis_config.data_ga_property = 'UA-15921884-1', addthis_config.data_ga_social = true; addthis_config.pubid = 'ra-53bef79866d02ea7'; //console.log(addthis_config); This past year Alexander & Baldwin announced, like many Hawaii commercial real estate companies before it, that it too, would become a real estate investment trust. At this rate, I too, would like to be a REIT, but alas, a REIT requires a minimum of 100 shareholders and I barely have that many Facebook friends. The details of the taxation of REITs have been hashed through before in Civil Beat by Anita Hofschneider and Michael Fergus (one of the lone crusaders in this REIT fight), but here’s the CliffsNotes version C corporations (corporations that are taxed separately from its owners), like A&B, are traditionally subject to double taxation: corporate taxation and individual taxation. Pass-through entities such as partnerships and S corporations (corporations that elect to pass corporate income, losses, deductions and credits through to their shareholders for federal tax purposes) are subject to one level of taxation, the individual level. The Alexander & Baldwin building in downtown HonoluluThe company has moved to become a REIT.Flickr: billsoPHOTO Becoming a REIT for federal tax purposes allows a C corporation to be taxed like a pass-through entity, with one level of taxation, and that is, individual taxation.  Where REITs differ from pass-through entities is for state income taxIncome earned on real estate in Hawaii is generally considered Hawaii sourced for pass-through entities, meaning the owners pay Hawaii income tax on the individual level on that income even if they’re non-residents. That same income earned in a C corporation pays Hawaii income tax, but only at the corporate levelOn the second layer of taxation, the individual level, the income is sourced to the state the owner is a resident ofFor a REIT and its one layer of taxation, all the income is sourced to the state of residence of the owner, meaning if you’re a non-Hawaii resident, all your income from a REIT avoids Hawaii income tax.  The result is out-of-state investors in Hawaii property are either subject to Hawaii income tax (if structured as a pass-through entity) or not subject to Hawaii tax (if structured as a REIT)Similarly, when an out-of-state investor purchases property directly in Hawaii and rents it out, the rental income is subject to Hawaii income tax. New Reasons To Address The Issue The REIT and state income tax issue has been studied and looked at by Hawaii lawmakersBut there might be a few new reasons to readdress the issue, including the addition of A&B (one of Hawaii’s largest real estate owners) to the REIT club for 2017.  Another reason to rehash the issue is the new tax billThe bill includes a 20 percent deduction for income coming from a pass-through entity, which also will include REIT payoutsIt suddenly appears A&B shareholders are about to have a windfall of tax savings, particularly the out-of-state owners. I like to think a tax break on the federal level might give Hawaii ample opportunity to sneak in there and increase Hawaii taxes before taxpayers get used to their new tax bill.  The final reason is for tax year 2018, Hawaii brings back the top 11 percent marginal income tax rate, which is one of the highest state income tax rates in the nation.  That means that if two investors in A&B, one from Hawaii and one from Texas (no state income tax), get together, the Texan should be obligated to pick up the bill until Hawaii lawmakers figure out a way to level the playing field.  Community Voices aims to encourage broad discussion on many topics of community interestIt’s kind of a cross between Letters to the Editor and op-edsThis is your space to talk about important issues or interesting people who are making a difference in our worldColumns generally run about 800 words (yes, they can be shorter or longer) and we need a photo of the author and a bioWe welcome video commentary and other multimedia formatsSend to news@civilbeat.com. About the Author Andrea Carr Andrea Carr prepares tax returns professionally and is a CPA licensed in Hawaii. You can follow her on Twitter at @andreacpa0. Use the RSS feed to subscribe to Andrea Carr's posts today Show Comments Support Nonprofit Journalism in Hawaii SorryThe minimumum donation amount is $5.00 I would like to donate $ One-Time Monthly Yearly Support Us Top Stories Cory Lum/Civil Beat ‘Devastation’ Discovered In Deep Sea From Industrial Fishing Tracy Wright Corvo Trump Nominates Honolulu Attorney Jill Otake For Federal Judgeship Cory Lum/Civil Beat Honolulu Mayor Kirk Caldwell Builds A New-Look Police Commission Cory Lum/Civil Beat Hawaii Delegates Speak Out Against GOP Tax Bill ‘Scam’ Flickr: Deb Nystrom Helicopters Endlessly Shatter The Quiet Of A Kauai Canyon Flickr: Deb Nystrom Helicopters Endlessly Shatter The Quiet Of A Kauai Canyon Sign up for our FREE morning newsletter and face each day more informed. Sign Me Up! SorryThat's an invalid e-mail. Thanks! We'll send you a confirmation e-mail shortly. And don't worry, we hate spam too! You can unsubscribe any time. The only news outlet in Hawaii dedicated to public affairs reporting Our mission is to engage and educate the community on important public issues through in-depth reporting, explanatory and investigative journalism, analysis and commentary Best Overall News Site Civil Beat has been named the best overall news site in Hawaii for the 7th year in a row by the Society of Professional Journalists Hawaii Chapter. Member About Civil Beat Member Benefits Contact Us Events Jobs FAQ Got A Tip? Podcasts Privacy Policy Reprint Policy Corporate Donations Terms of Service

Trending Hawaii News:


  • Lehman Seeks Title to Ritz-Carlton Kapalua Resort in Hawaii
  • Eileen Lacerte Accepted into Forbes Real Estate Council
  • Hawaii's Top Real Estate Team Endorsed By Country Music Star
  • The Home of Hawaii’s Realtors for 50 Years
  • Celebrity Real Estate: Kardashians, Terry Bradshaw, Liev Schreiber
  • POLL: Does Hawaii Kai need another grocery store?
  • Waipahu, HI Homes For Sale & Real Estate
  • Content, not ‘nontent’: Reimagining real estate signs
  • LOG IN
  • 3 file suit in alleged Puna land scam
  • Hawaii's 2nd-largest retail company buys 3 shopping centers
  • Solo sailor expects to reach Hawaii early next week
  • Honolulu Real Estate Trends: What's Next?
  • Hawaiian tropic: Are Obamas privately eyeing Magnum, P.I. home?
  • Hawaii realtors see change in Japanese buyers after deadly tsunami
  • Korean investors buy Walgreens flagship Honolulu store for $42M
  • District 02 – Margarita “Dayday” Hopkins
  • AANlive Expands Real Estate to Include Luxury Properties
  • Colliers: Honolulu industrial market improves
  • In Hawaii, 1 of every 24 homes is a vacation rental