Real Estate News
--> Texas News
Texas Home Equity Loan Amendments Enacted
Proposition 2 amended Article XVI, Section 50 of the Texas Constitution, which addresses the protection of homes from forced sales for payments of debts. In order to create a valid lien on a Texas homestead property (and hence, be able to foreclose on the ...
Texans approved a constitutional amendment changing the state’s home equity loan landscape beginning January 1Our Financial Services & Products Group examines the new law and its implications and limitations.
What does Proposition 2 do?
Section 50(a)(6) loans
The statute of limitations
In a little-noticed development, in May 2017, the Texas Legislature enacted Senate Joint Resolution 60 (S.J.R60) proposing amendments to the Texas Constitution affecting home equity lendingThe Resolution, known as Texas Proposition 2, was placed on the ballot on November 7, 2017, and approved overwhelmingly by votersNotably, Proposition 2: (1) lowers the cap on home equity loan related fees from 3 percent to 2 percent but excludes certain additional fees from being included in this limit; (2) allows home equity loans secured by agricultural property; (3) permits the refinancing of a home equity loan with a purchase money loan; and (4) allows advances on a home equity line of credit (HELOC) as long as the principal amount remains at 80 percent of the fair market value (FMV) of a borrower’s houseThe amendments take effect on January 1, 2018, and apply to all home equity loans originated on or after that date.
Proposition 2 amended Article XVI, Section 50 of the Texas Constitution, which addresses the protection of homes from forced sales for payments of debtsIn order to create a valid lien on a Texas homestead property (and hence, be able to foreclose on the mortgaged property), Texas home equity loans created pursuant to Section 50(a)(6), including HELOCs, must comply with a number of conditionsSignificantly, failure to comply with these conditions could expose the holder of the loan to possible forfeiture of all principal and interest on the loan.
Before the enactment of the amendments, lenders were prohibited from charging certain loan-related fees that exceeded 3 percent of the loan amount, excluding certain charges such as interestWhile Proposition 2 lowered this cap on fees from 3 percent to 2 percent, it notably excludes from the cap costly loan-related fees such as appraisals, property surveys, title insurance premiums, and title examinations, which effectively allows lenders to exclude more charges from the fee cap.
Before Proposition 2, a Section 50(a)(6) loan could not be secured by homestead property designated for agricultural use except for properties used primarily for the production of milkThe amendments permit owners of houses on land classified as agricultural to enter into voluntary liens to secure home equity loans.
Refinancing a Home Equity Loan
Before the amendments, once a borrower obtained a Section 50(a)(6) loan, any subsequent refinancing of the loan (secured by the homestead property) would still be subject to the restrictions of Section 50(a)(6), even if the borrower did not receive any cash from the refinanced proceedsProposition 2 permits a borrower to combine a home equity loan with a loan taken to buy a house (e.g., a purchase money loan)It allows a borrower to refinance these two types of loans into one home equity or non-home equity loan with one rate and one term if four conditions are satisfied:
The refinanced loan is originated at least a year after the original home equity loan was consummated.
The refinanced loan does not provide additional funds to the borrower other than to cover the costs of the refinancing.
The refinanced loan does not exceed 80 percent of the FMV of the house.
At least 12 days before the refinancing, the lender provides the borrower with a special notice regarding certain rights associated with the new loan.
Proposition 2 eliminates the restriction on advances under a HELOC that prevented such advances if the principal amount of the debt was more than 50 percent of the FMV of the houseThe amendment allows advances under the HELOC as long as the principal amount of the debt does not exceed 80 percent of the FMV of the house.
Proposition 2 clarifies that entities regulated as “mortgage bankers” or “mortgage brokers,” as well as subsidiaries of banks, savings and loan associations, savings banks, and credit unions, are authorized to make home equity loans in Texas.
Alston & Bird Observations
Proposition 2 is a welcome development that should enhance home equity lending in Texas by eliminating certain restrictions and making notable clarifications to the complex Texas constitutional provisionsUnfortunately, the amendments do not clarify the statute of limitation period for asserting claims or defenses under Section 50(a)(6)In the past, lenders and their assignees have relied on an absolute four-year statute of limitations period (four years from when the loan was originated)In other words, after four years of seasoning, the borrower was unable to raise a violation of the Section 50(a)(6) constitutional provisionIn May 2016, however, the Texas Supreme Court ruled in effect that holders of Section 50(a)(6) loans could not rely on the four-year statute of limitations if there was in fact a violation of the statuteWe had hoped that the Texas legislature would ultimately clarify this issue in its amendments.
Download PDF of Advisory
Latest PostsTexas Home Equity Loan Amendments Enacted
Alston & Bird Healthcare Week in Review
Salary History Questions Are History
Data Protection Litigation to Become a New Reality in Belgium
CPSC Recall Snapshot – Changes at the CPSC
See more »
DISCLAIMER: Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations.
Trending Texas News:
Morning Briefing: Texas housing market defies economic slowdown
Texas small land sales jump 14 percent, price per acre declines in 2016
Brinkmann Ranch Partial Sale Could Be First Of Many
Effort to overhaul Texas voter ID rules survives — for now
Report calls Texas nursing homes 'shamefully poor'
Hot Austin real estate market starts 2017 with surge in sales
First quarter sets aggressive pace for Texas real estate this year
Would-be Homebuyers Consider Remodeling Instead
Supreme Auctions Offers Rare No Reserve Auction of Custom Built Luxury Estate in Exclusive Houston Community
Duke Bridges III Sold in Frisco’s $5 Billion Mile
Marcus Hiles -- Brings Environmental Responsibility to Housing Developments
Local real estate agent arrested for theft
Meritage Homes reports preliminary home closings, orders, and backlog for the third quarter of 2017
Capitol Report: Oil crash may whack earnings of top U.S. home builders in Texas
National Asset Services Delivers Cumulative Return-on-Investment of Over 109% for Investors in Texas Student Housing Property
Local firms make $111M deal for Texas properties
Local support growing for new Entergy Texas power plant near Willis
The Price of Texas Growth: Housing Affordability
Texas Grand Ranch honors commitment to the community.
Noble Capital and US Capital unveils $250 mln Texas real estate fund