Real Estate News
--> Utah News
A Narrow Breastfeeding Victory In Utah Shows Policymakers Are Still Afraid Of Nipples
Utah currently exempts breastfeeding moms from indecent exposure ... nursing in public if for no other reason than it makes it possible for them to leave their homes for more than an hour or two at a time. “If anyone has a problem seeing a woman feeding ...
Nearly every state in the country, with the exception of Idaho and Utah, has a law specifically allowing women to breastfeed in public without fear of being asked to leave ? a legislative nod to the fact that doctors, major medical organizations and even the United States government all urge new moms to breastfeed.
Breastfeeding has been a public health priority for decades, with groups like the American Academy of Pediatrics touting benefits like decreased risk of infection and sudden infant death syndromeDespite this, anemic legal protections and a culture of shame around public breastfeeding contribute to the fact that only 27 percent of American moms breastfeed their babies for a full year.
Utah currently exempts breastfeeding moms from indecent exposure laws, but stops short of stating outright that they can breastfeed in publicThat means nursing mothers can still be asked to leave public spaces, state RepJustin Fawson (R), who sponsored the state’s Breastfeeding Protection Act, meant to cement the right to breastfeed in public, told HuffPost.
But the bill almost didn’t pass through Utah’s House Business and Labor Committee this week, with six votes for it and five against — all from menThe legislation’s narrow passage through committee shows that judgment of breastfeeding mothers is alive and well, and exemplifies why a 2011 Surgeon General report found that embarrassment remains a “formidable” barrier to breastfeeding for American moms, according to DrJoan Younger Meek, chair of the American Academy of Pediatrics’ section on breastfeeding.
The bill would clarify that women can nurse in public “irrespective of whether the woman’s breast is uncovered during or incidental to the breastfeeding.”
And it is that last part — the possibility that a woman’s chest might be exposed while she is, say, fastening her bra, or if her baby happens to move its head to look around — that made state RepCurt Webb (R) uncomfortable.
“This seems to say you don’t have to cover up at all,” Webb said, according to The Salt Lake Tribune“I’m not comfortable with that, I’m just notIt’s really in your face.”
I wish that I could say that I am surprised that five men voted against protections for women breastfeeding in public, but I am not.
DrJoan Younger Meek, American Academy of Pediatrics
Male lawmakers have previously expressed concern about the potential of seeing a breastfeeding woman’s nipplesIn 2015, a New Hampshire state representative drew national attention for his (quickly deleted) Facebook comment saying, “if it’s a woman’s natural inclination to pull her nipple out in public and you support that, than you should have no problem with a mans inclantion [sic] to stare at it and grab it.”
Last fall, the city council in in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, voted to ban children from its meetings after several members complained about seeing one of their colleagues breastfeed during a meeting — though it wasn’t just male councilmembers who voted for the ban.
The reality is, babies eat oftenYoung infants can be counted on to nurse at least every two to three hoursLactation experts say women must have the option of nursing in public if for no other reason than it makes it possible for them to leave their homes for more than an hour or two at a time.
“If anyone has a problem seeing a woman feeding her child, you have to ask ‘Why?’” said Julie Matheney, a Los Angeles-based lactation consultant“Why are you having a problem with it, when that’s what the breast is designed for? It’s a feeding organ.”
In an email to HuffPost, Webb stood by his comments.
“I agree that breastfeeding is extremely beneficial to infantsI believe that mothers should be free to do so, and I also believe that doing so in public is acceptable,” he wrote“However, I also believe that most of my constituents prefer that nursing in public should be done discreetlyThe wording of the bill as presented in committee, specifically excluded any requirement to be considerate of the feelings or sensitivities of others.”
“I do not believe that there is any malice or character flaw in those traditional values of modesty,” he added.
Yet while even the pope has encouraged public breastfeeding several times, calling it the “language of love,” research suggests Webb is not alone in his opinion.
“I wish that I could say that I am surprised that five men voted against protections for women breastfeeding in public, but I am not,” said Meek, of the American Academy of Pediatrics.
A 2014 phone survey in New York found that 50 percent of respondents did not approve of public breastfeeding, while a 2016 study out of the United Kingdom found a majority of commenters supported public breastfeeding when it is discreet.
The question, of course, is what “discreet” public breastfeeding meansThough some women prefer to use a nursing cover, many babies simply will not tolerate them, Matheney said.
“While most mothers are discreet when nursing, if there is exposure of the breast in the act of breastfeeding the infant or child, the women should be protected,” Meek said“If we believe that breastfeeding is a vital matter of public health for mothers and children, we should be supporting it in all venues, and legislative protection is a part of that support.”
Fawson agrees, telling HuffPost he is confident the bill he sponsored will pass when it is heard on the House floor.
“I think it’s shocking that there remains a perception by some that breastfeeding is anything other than a ‘normal’ and ‘natural’ function,” he said“To see the act of a mother feeding her baby as a sexualized act is surprising to me.”
BEFORE YOU GO
Catherine PearsonWomen & Parents Senior Reporter, HuffPost
Trending Utah News:
Flood Emergency Declared at Utah Dam During Heavy Snowmelt
Juab County recorder behaved unethically, state commission says
Utah CEOs honored as Entrepreneur of the Year
Reading by acclaimed poet David Lee Dec. 3 in Silver City
Utah leaders consider prison reforms
VidAngel Charts Path Forward, CEO Announces Innovative VidAngel Studios
British Socialists and Utah Republicans Have the Same Good Idea on How to End Homelessness
Mission improbable: Cooke takes on Herbert
Nephi, UT Homes For Sale & Real Estate
Six ex-Novell buildings sold to become tech park
Jon Huntsman buys Fred Thompson’s house in Virginia
Groups rank Utah No. 1 pro-business state for 2012
Op-ed: As potters at the wheel, let us shape Utah from inside and outside
ION Solar Launches ION Earth Program, Donating Custom Solar Systems To Homes In Need And Easing The Burden Of High Cost Utilities
In our opinion: Welcoming refugees in rural communities
Fire in Utah City Isn’t Expected to Drive up Insurance Rates
From Utah to Finland, “This is Home” hits the slopes for white-knuckle skiing
Utah’s Extra Space Storage reports higher 4Q results
Herriman, UT Homes For Sale & Real Estate
Utah State Amateur golf tournament: Wright fulfills expectations with victory at State Am