Find Real Estate Agents and Homes for Sale

Real Estate News --> California News

California Housing Revolution?

From downtown Los Angeles to Santa Monica, train commuters on the Expo Line journey from asphalt to ocean through some of the most expensive real estate in the United States ... Nearly a third of households in California’s metro areas can’t afford ...

Archived Story

City Journal is a publication of Manhattan Institute Search search Experts Heather Mac Donald Topics Health Care Publications Health in New York Heat Infrastructure Heart of US Economics On the Ground Health in New York Heat Infrastructure Heart of US Economics Projects Health in New York Heat Infrastructure Heart of US Economics Trending The Magazine TopicsArts & Culture California Cities Economy, Finance, Budgets Education Healthcare Infrastructure & Energy New York Politics & Law Public Safety Technology & Innovation The Social Order Texas Other Contributors Books Multimedia All Publications About Praise Subscribe City Journal search Close Nav Search Close Search search Share this article on Facebook Twitter Google Plus Email Close California Housing Revolution? Share eye on the news California Housing Revolution? A pro-market proposal from a liberal state senator offers hope for solving the state’s chronic shortage and high prices. Michael Hendrix February 21, 2018 CaliforniaEconomy, finance, and budgets From downtown Los Angeles to Santa Monica, train commuters on the Expo Line journey from asphalt to ocean through some of the most expensive real estate in the United StatesEach train pulls into stations of low-slung buildings that soon fade into vast expanses of single-family homesThe view from Los Angeles is hardly uniqueCommuters from San Diego to the Bay Area and Sacramento see low-rise suburbs as the normAnd everything costs a fortune.  That might begin to change if the state legislature passes a bill addressing local land-use regulationsIntroduced by Scott Wiener, a Harvard-educated attorney and state senator, SB 827 would effectively abolish zoning restrictions in Wiener’s district of San Francisco and for significant portions of the state’s most populous areas—and likely produce a boom in new housing constructionSB 827 sweeps away many local limits on height, density, and design within a half-mile of a train station—such as for BART or CalTrain—and within a quarter-mile of stops on high-frequency bus routesSo-called transit-rich zones would see local height limits lifted to anywhere from 45 feet to 85 feet—roughly from four to eight stories—depending on factors such as street width and station proximityCities could build taller, but they could not require that buildings be shorterNew projects built near transit hubs would also be exempted from minimum parking requirementsAnd as long as a particular project is up to code, no municipality could introduce design standards preventing developers from including the maximum number of units possible in a building. Wiener hopes to fight sprawl by allowing Californians more opportunities to live closer to public transit, and to address climate concerns by reducing their need to driveTo Wiener, a liberal Democrat, housing is also about social justiceHe believes progressives have “lost their way on housing,” as he told Forbes recentlyYoung people, the poor, and the elderly are demanding shelter only to find its supply limited by stringent regulations“Gentrification is fueled by a lack of housing,” Wiener argues“When there isn’t enough housing and rents skyrocket, landlords have an economic incentive to push out long-term renters by raising the rent or evicting them.” Nearly a third of households in California’s metro areas can’t afford rent, according to the McKinsey Global InstituteA majority of these rent-squeezed households—some 3.7 million—are in Los Angeles and the Bay AreaIn San Francisco and Oakland, even making $90,000 a year barely puts one above the affordability thresholdCalifornia’s affordability crisis is rooted in a housing crisis: not nearly enough homes are being built to keep up with demand“We under-produce by about 100,000 housing units every year, and we have a housing debt that’s growing,” Wiener saysThe most feasible way to pay off that housing debt, he believes, is to let developers build more units in concentrated areas. Housing is the most pressing issue in California politicsLast year, Governor Jerry Brown signed 15 bills aimed at tackling housing affordabilitySenate Bill 35, for instance, forces almost all of California’s cities to approve projects that complied with current zoning rulesAnother bill placed a measure on the 2018 ballot directing nearly $1 billion a year to subsidize new low-income housingThese efforts are part of a growing trend in Sacramento to preempt local restrictions on housingSome of these measures, such as a 2016 law easing the approval of new “accessory dwelling units” statewide, appear to be workingLos Angeles is seeing a 20-fold rise in applications for these so-called “granny flats,” built in backyards or above garages. Transit-oriented development has assumed sacred status among Yes In My Backyard (YIMBY) progressives popping up across CaliforniaThe ideal scenario for lowering the barriers to housing density near transit is to get more with less: more housing and affordability with less displacement and sprawlThe result is a traditional Main Street for the twenty-first centuryAfter all, compact, mixed-use developments, accessible by foot, were the norm until the rise of the automobile and institution of zoning laws. Building more housing is broadly popular in CaliforniaSixty-four percent are in favor of more housing in their cities, according to a PPIC poll of the stateIn San Francisco, some 70 percent support building more housing to alleviate cost burdensLeaders in Los Angeles have formulated a plan to add 6,000 new homes within a half-mile of Expo Line stops between Culver City and Santa Monica. Of course, building in someone else’s backyard is always more popular than construction in your ownMost instances of transit-oriented development, such as the kind that Arlington, Virginia, has pursued, take the shape of a corridor running through—but not impinging on—preexisting tracts of single-family homesLos Angeles’s Expo Line housing plan up-zoned 250 acres while leaving the surrounding 2,000 acres of homes untouched. Wiener’s proposal is more aggressive: it would immediately up-zone nearly all of San Francisco, as well as South Los Angeles’s sprawling landscape of single-family homesTransit corridors in Oakland, San Diego, San Jose, and Sacramento would be able to build for demandNearly 3 million housing units could be situated within a half-mile of transit hubs throughout CaliforniaWith fewer permitting rules, units could be built faster and with a greater variety of housing types between a home and a high-rise. Critics of SB 827 fear displacementLos Angeles city councilman Paul Koretz has labeled SB 827 “devastating,” telling the Los Angeles Times that his Westside neighborhood of “little 1920s, ‘30s and ‘40s single-family homes [would] look like Dubai 10 years later,” and without any public say in the matterDamien Goodmon, founder of the Crenshaw Subway Coalition in Los Angeles, calls the bill a “declaration of war,” seeing it as a mask for large-scale gentrificationLaying on the hyperbole, Goodmon calls Wiener “a modern-day Andrew Jackson” pushing “a legislative agenda to enact a 21st century Trail of Tears.” Housing availability does not mean housing affordability, these critics say; only subsidies and public housing can achieve that. Wiener acknowledges that his bill is a “heavy lift and isn’t guaranteed to pass” in its current formThere will likely be revisions as it winds its way through committee, with added provisions addressing housing displacement and demolitionObservers believe that Governor Brown, in his final year in office, would likely sign such a bill if it reached his desk.  But whether it passes or not, SB 827 shifts the window of acceptable discourse dramatically in favor of market-oriented reforms of housing policyOn that basis alone, Scott Wiener has positioned himself as a visionary reformer of California’s housing crisis. Michael Hendrix is director of state and local policy at the Manhattan Institute. Photo: marekuliasz/iStock Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Google Plus Email Print Sign up for Email Alerts More from Michael Hendrix eye on the news Memphis Brews Development Michael Hendrix A civic demonstration project breathes new life into a cherished landmark. eye on the news A Tale of Two Taxi Cities Michael Hendrix London and New York struggle to get along with Uber. eye on the news The Mall Rises Again Michael Hendrix How to breathe new life into America’s much-maligned indoor shopping centers. More on California eye on the news Hypocrisy, Inc. Larry Sand Teachers’ union leaders grandstand about evil corporations while drawing fat salaries. eye on the news Brown Bows Out Lloyd Billingsley California’s recurring governor delivers his final State of the State speech. eye on the news Water from the Sands Kerry Jackson Environmental radicals in California are trying to derail a sensible and responsible water-reclamation project. Up Next eye on the news Memphis Brews Development A civic demonstration project breathes new life into a cherished landmark. Michael Hendrix October 20, 2015 City Journal A quarterly magazine of urban affairs, published by the Manhattan Institute, edited by Brian CAnderson. The Magazine Books Multimedia All Publications Subscribe About Praise Contact Advertise Privacy Policy TopicsArts & Culture California Cities Economy, Finance, Budgets Education Healthcare Infrastructure & Energy New York Politics & Law Public Safety Technology & Innovation Texas Other ContributorsBrian CAnderson Seth Barron Michael Knox Beran Claire Berlinski Paul Beston Ben Boychuk Theodore Dalrymple Nicole Gelinas Edward LGlaeser Victor Davis Hanson Howard Husock Kay SHymowitz Stefan Kanfer Andrew Klavan Joel Kotkin John Leo Heather Mac Donald Myron Magnet Steven Malanga John OMcGinnis Bob McManus Judith Miller Peter Reinharz Aaron MRenn Fred Siegel Guy Sorman Harry Stein John Tierney Michael JTotten Mene Ukueberuwa Adam White 52 Vanderbilt AvenueNew York, NY 10017 (212) 599-7000 City Journal on Facebook City Journal on Twitter City Journal on Google Plus City Journal on YouTube City Journal on Instagram City Journal RSS

Trending California News:

  • 6 States With the Biggest Real Estate Bubbles
  • Partner in major venture capital firm buys Hawaii estate
  • Can immigrants rescue housing?
  • The latest apartment buy: $76M for 390 units in Happy Valley
  • SpaceList and Common Areas Form Strategic International Alliance to Connect Commercial Real Estate--from Listing to Lawns, Leaks and Lights
  • High-end home sales surge in Southern California
  • 5 NFL Franchise Owners With Impressive Real Estate
  • 10 Outdoor Living Ideas to Steal from California
  • DJM Real Estate Retained by RadioShack Corporation to Dispose of Seven Industrial Properties in the United States
  • Closer Look at the Correlation of Southern California Divorce and Foreclosure
  • Hesperia, CA Homes For Sale & Real Estate
  • Lopsided Housing Rebound Leaves Millions of People Out in the Cold
  • Chinese money could flow away from Southern California if Trump sparks a trade war
  • Texas tops Calif. in ranking as most overvalued housing market
  • Sonoma Valley, CA Real Estate: Newly Listed Homes for Sale
  • It’s Your First Look at BRAVO’s New “Real Estate Wars” – Starting October 5!
  • Eagle Rock, CA Real Estate: Newly Listed Homes for Sale
  • Bundle Select is Changing the World of Real Estate
  • Trump loves winning, but in his presidency and business, California has gotten in his way
  • In California Suit Federal Judge Certifies Class Action of Investors Against Coldwell Banker Real Estate Corporation ...